Hey guys, today, for the second time I got this problem of "Critically Low Voltage Warning", luckily in both times I was about to land and very close to the drone.

In the first time (2 months ago) it was about 15%, landing, and then it dropped to zero. Today it was 23% when dropped to zero. I can't say if it was the same battery. I've seen other mavic air users with this problem, now I'm getting worried about this, because depending on where it happens can be catastrophic.

Flight Log  -  https://drive.google.com/file/d/ ... 3o/view?usp=sharing


This was the 3rd flight of the day, with the 3rd battery, at this point everythig was ok and I was coming for landing:



5 seconds later it dropped to zero with the error:

Hello and good day JonnyHammer. I am sorry for the trouble this has caused and thank you for reaching out. Can you please refresh the firmware of your DJI Mavic Air and see if the issue will still perstst? In addition this issue was due to battery communication is not working properly. I would recommend checking the pins on the battery as well on the aircraft if it has damage. If none, you may clean the pins using the dry soft brush to check if there will be changes or if you would encounter this error message again. Please keep us posted on the latest progress. Thank you for your support and fly safe always.

Hiya,

Looks like a bad #2 cell, see chart.



cheers
JJB

JJB* Posted at 1-17 11:50
Hiya,

Looks like a bad #2 cell, see chart.

I just downloaded your software and analyzing I can see clearly that the cell 2 of battery 36446 is not functioning properly, it varies up to 1300 mV, my other 2 batteries varies approximately  50 mV:

DJI Stephen Posted at 1-17 11:46
Hello and good day JonnyHammer. I am sorry for the trouble this has caused and thank you for reaching out. Can you please refresh the firmware of your DJI Mavic Air and see if the issue will still perstst? In addition this issue was due to battery communication is not working properly. I would recommend checking the pins on the battery as well on the aircraft if it has damage. If none, you may clean the pins using the dry soft brush to check if there will be changes or if you would encounter this error message again. Please keep us posted on the latest progress. Thank you for your support and fly safe always.

Yes everything is clean, updated and calibrated, it's an issue in a cell in one of my batteries.

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-17 12:11
I just downloaded your software and analyzing I can see clearly that the cell 2 of battery 36446 is not functioning properly, it varies up to 1300 mV, my other 2 batteries varies approximately  50 mV:

[view_image]

Have fun with FRAP   ;-)

JJB* Posted at 1-18 01:08
Have fun with FRAP   ;-)

Very good software indeed, but I can't resize or make it full window, so the bottom doesn't appear to me. I can't see the graphs below because of that.

Time for a new battery before you loose your drone.

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 07:24
Very good software indeed, but I can't resize or make it full window, so the bottom doesn't appear to me. I can't see the graphs below because of that.

Sorry, minimum resolution is a FHD screen.
What resolution do you use?

Plus / Min ?

cheers
JJB

JJB* Posted at 1-18 09:00
Sorry, minimum resolution is a FHD screen.
What resolution do you use?

I use Full HD - 1920 x 1080

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 11:07
I use Full HD - 1920 x 1080

oke,

if you select MINUS sign ; FRAP uses 1624 x 948;

cheers
JJB

JJB* Posted at 1-18 11:36
oke,

if you select MINUS sign ; FRAP uses 1624 x 948;

Ok now I can see all, thanks a lot, very nice job on the software!

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 12:48
Ok now I can see all, thanks a lot, very nice job on the software!

Yeah, FRAP is a nice piece of software.

Another alternative or complement is--> Airdata
Free to use with most of the useful functions & possibility to store 100 flight logs (Free account). The possibility that gives you is that you can monitor the slight degradation of batteries over time and take them off duty before something as your event happens.The only thing you need to do to have the logs automatic uploaded to Airdata is to sync your flight logs in the GO4 app to DJI servers then specify your DJI login under the Airdata account details.

Your battery from your flight log:



This is from one of my worst MA batteries, combining hundreds of flights ...

Lucas775 Posted at 1-18 07:52
Time for a new battery before you loose your drone.

Yeah, I'll see if I can recover the cell by making some dull discharges, if not I'll dispose it

slup Posted at 1-18 16:04
Yeah, FRAP is a nice piece of software.

Another alternative or complement is--> Airdata

Thanks so much, the results are pretty much the same of FRAP, but I'll definetly check airdata as well in the future.

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 16:58
Yeah, I'll see if I can recover the cell by making some dull discharges, if not I'll dispose it

Good luck with it, i'll be following this thread.

slup Posted at 1-18 16:04
Yeah, FRAP is a nice piece of software.

Another alternative or complement is--> Airdata

Hi,

Thanks, yes FRAP is nice  ;-)    imo it does give more insight in the combination and interaction of data in the various charts.

But what counts for each software tool, none is perfect and FRAP isn`t perfect too.
In the latest version user can check if drone looses height with no input, or doesn`t want to go up with RC stick up....etc.

cheers
JJB

JJB* Posted at 1-19 02:39
Hi,

Thanks, yes FRAP is nice  ;-)    imo it does give more insight in the combination and interaction of data in the various charts.

Hi JJB,

I have not yet managed to run FRAP in windows 7. Any advice?

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 16:58
Yeah, I'll see if I can recover the cell by making some dull discharges, if not I'll dispose it

How many charge cycles does the battery have with the wrong cell?

QQRUCH Posted at 1-19 04:52
Hi JJB,

I have not yet managed to run FRAP in windows 7. Any advice?

Oops, no i have not, well....the only advise is to update to W10.

QQRUCH Posted at 1-19 04:54
How many charge cycles does the battery have with the wrong cell?

Around 30, it's from may 2018, relatively new.

Last year it stayed around 4 months without use, half-charge around 60%, but the other two batteries stayed as well and they are fine.

*WHY* the drone don´t warn us about cell deviation during flight?????

Adriano Araujo Posted at 1-20 05:49
*WHY* the drone don´t warn us about cell deviation during flight?????

That's exactly what I was thinking, DJI should do something about this otherwise many people will lost their drones because of that, cell deviation is a very common problem.

In this video DJI GO shows an option "Show Voltage on Main Screen", but my DJI GO doesn't have this:




After I analyzed the parameters, the "Critically Low Voltage Warning" appears when the cell deviation is above 1000 Mv, so this isn't a warning, is more like a mayday emergency situation right?

A warning should be given when the cell deviation hits around 500 mV, so the operator could have time to assess the situation and bring it back safely, imagine if it happens in a long range? I've already put my mavic 2,2 km away

Anyways for now I set my Fn button in the controller to display the battery screen on DJI GO, so I can monitor the deviation before it's critical.

JJB* Posted at 1-19 06:31
Oops, no i have not, well....the only advise is to update to W10.

oky!

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 16:58
Yeah, I'll see if I can recover the cell by making some dull discharges, if not I'll dispose it

Never on purpose let the battery down to 0% ... discharge to 8% the charge to 100%.

The gain of this kind of "battery service" is largely debated ... mainly it somewhat suppose to restore the batteries maximum charge capacity nothing more.

When it comes to your battery this will not "repair" it ... that battery is shot, dispose of it, it's just a matter of time until this happens again and then you perhaps aren't so lucky.

JonnyHammer Posted at 1-18 17:06
Thanks so much, the results are pretty much the same of FRAP, but I'll definetly check airdata as well in the future.

The pros of Airdata.com over FRAP is that it provide you with an easy hands off workflow to get all your logs in the same place, and by that gives you the possibility to monitor the trend of a battery & draw conclusions from that.

My worst battery shown from Airdata in my earlier post is placed under monitoring, after each flight I check the trend to be prepared to take it off duty. For instance I never use that battery in colder weather.

I bet that your battery had been questioned by critical eyes long before this happened if the trends had been available.

slup Posted at 1-20 23:34
The pros of Airdata.com over FRAP is that it provide you with an easy hands off workflow to get all your logs in the same place, and by that gives you the possibility to monitor the trend of a battery & draw conclusions from that.

My worst battery shown from Airdata in my earlier post is placed under monitoring, after each flight I check the trend to be prepared to take it off duty. For instance I never use that battery in colder weather.

Hi slup,

Thanks for the idea of logging / trend values for batt values if FRAP as well.

cheers
JJB

slup Posted at 1-20 23:25
Never on purpose let the battery down to 0% ... discharge to 8% the charge to 100%.

The gain of this kind of "battery service" is largely debated ... mainly it somewhat suppose to restore the batteries maximum charge capacity nothing more.

I've read that it could maybe restore the defective cell, so I tried. The process is turning it on, without hovering, and let the battery discharge completely, but the mavic air shuts down when gets to 10%.

I'm not using this battery after the last incident. Maybe I'll keep to internal takes, sometimes I film houses and other properties to the real estate market, in these cases wouldn't be a problem.

slup Posted at 1-20 23:34
The pros of Airdata.com over FRAP is that it provide you with an easy hands off workflow to get all your logs in the same place, and by that gives you the possibility to monitor the trend of a battery & draw conclusions from that.

My worst battery shown from Airdata in my earlier post is placed under monitoring, after each flight I check the trend to be prepared to take it off duty. For instance I never use that battery in colder weather.

I f I knew this problem would occur in less than 2 years of use I'd watch it closely.

It's kind of disappointing that this battery is defective with around 30 cicles and less than 2 years.

From now on I'll analyze the logs for every flight and observe the trends.

JJB* Posted at 1-21 00:28
Hi slup,

Thanks for the idea of logging / trend values for batt values if FRAP as well.

Yeah ... that would be a good addition, I don't mind storing my device logs, both txt & dat locally.
If trend values over for instance calculated theoretical total flight time & cell deviations over time could be presented per battery identity out from a group of logs would be perfect.

If the other cells continue flawlessly the question remains why so shortchanged of longevity? Wasn't longevity specified 300 recharges cold and only 150 recharges warm?

Happened to me twice. The sedcond time, last week, I was extremely lucky to not loose my drone. Both times the drone behaved strangely right before the battery fail. As happened to many, many others, 1 cell gets bad while the other 2 are healthy. Surely a desing failure. And surely ridiculous DJI had done nothing about it. Not even updated the app to give some warnings about battery degradation.  
Last week, I've flown perfectly one day and literally the next day it failed midflight.  
One week later and I still cant believe how absurd this situation is without DJI doing anything about it. And I've ALWAYS followed all standard and recommended procedures.HOW CAN WE SAFELY FLY A DRONE WITH A BATTERY THAT MAY FAIL ANYTIME WITHOUT ABSOLUTELY NO SIGN OR WARNING?  Its a timebomb waiting to explode.

I still can't figure out why DJI put a "warning" only when the drone is at the point of making an emergency landing, and no previous warnings before the critical stage.

The battery is the fuel of the drone, so this is like an airplane with no indicators of fuel flow, only a warning message when it has almost no flow.... come on, this makes no sense at all.

We are tend to watch the battery percentage very closely, but this cell deviation is a very common problem that most drone operators are not aware of, until 2 weeks ago I didn't even know that this exists...

My defective battery was always stored with 60%, protected from heat and humidity, it's not swollen etc. It has a normal looking, but inside has a cell deviation of 1300 mV! With 30 cicles and less than 2 years of use, I'm very disappointed with this.

Hi there,

I have crashed my P3Pro and it seems battery failed see attached log, but I have heard some people get lower voltage then mine 11V and aircraft still was ok anyway I broke gimbal arm and wire tape, ordered repaired. Now Drone is connecting to the remote control fine I can see live picture from camera and gimbal works as before but get lound beeping sound just after switching on the aircraft same as this guy here on you tube exact title below:"DJI Drone won't stop beeping after Firmware update Phantom 3 Professional" Can not paste links as I am newbie sorry
I have followed steps he showed without success, after few minutes my light go solid red on the gimbal.

What I noticed my battery seems ok I can charge it and light bars works fine but there is no data when checking on DJI GO App it shows 0% on all cells 0V all options seems disable.
Rest looks fine I can format SD GPS ok etc via DJI GO App

From SD Card hidden file "3X_FW_LOG_AB" I have noticed few modules not deceted as showed below, but for some people in similar case reinstal firmware helped:

[00012604]========== remo-con disconnect. boot(15) ============
[00012681]Packet [C:\P3X_FW_V01.11.0020.bin] detected, card sn [0xe4dd0630].
[00012753]Packet upgrade start...

[00012836]Packet checking...
[00012908]Packet vlink 01.11.0020 <-> 01.11.0020.
[00012985]Record vlink 01.11.0020 <-> 01.11.0020 (flow = 0).
[00013059]Done.

[00013127]Version checking[1]...
[00025701][03 06][00] device not detected.
[00038271][03 05][00] device not detected.
[00038478][04 00][00] v1.48.0.0 -> v1.48.0.0
[00051052][11 00][00] device not detected.
[00063621][11 01][00] device not detected.
[00076200][12 00][00] device not detected.
[00088774][12 01][00] device not detected.
[00101348][12 02][00] device not detected.
[00113930][12 03][00] device not detected.
[00114095][15 00][00] v1.1.2.0 -> v1.1.2.0
[00126661][17 00][00] device not detected.
[00139231][17 01][00] device not detected.
[00139325][19 00][00] v1.0.8.96 -> v1.0.8.96
[00139395][01 00][00] v1.32.5432 -> v1.32.5432
[00139471][01 01][00] v1.32.5432 -> v1.32.5432
[00139561][08 00][00] v0.13.0.7 -> v0.13.0.7
[00139665][09 00][00] v4.1.0.0 -> v4.1.0.0
[00139735]Packet upgrade failed at version checking.


Do you thing that can be just battery problem and that is why I get very lound beeping, and can not get it working?

Can not paste files here as I am newbi but can email or PM
drive.   google.com/drive/folders/1E0Zr1GZpWl-qveOquo89MAL_DuxT86is?usp=sharing

Thx in advance

siwypfk Posted at 3-17 11:52
Hi there,

I have crashed my P3Pro and it seems battery failed see attached log, but I have heard some people get lower voltage then mine 11V and aircraft still was ok anyway I broke gimbal arm and wire tape, ordered repaired. Now Drone is connecting to the remote control fine I can see live picture from camera and gimbal works as before but get lound beeping sound just after switching on the aircraft same as this guy here on you tube exact title below:"DJI Drone won't stop beeping after Firmware update Phantom 3 Professional" Can not paste links as I am newbie sorry

Hey, I don't know how to help you because I don't use the phantom. I think it would be better if you open a new thread explaining your problem, here in this thread not many people will see it.

If you attach the log file people can help you more easily, hope you can fix the problem.

Hey guys, two days ago my drone crashed..... I was flying along then out of the blue my battery level dropped from 35 to 0 and I got a message saying critically low battery. I immediately turned around and started to go back to shore but it didn’t make it. I had full deflection forward and up but to no avail; it crashed about a 100 yards out and I wasn’t able to find it. The next morning I called DJI and told them everything but they pulled the stupid move. They said since it wasn’t under warranty anymore it wasn’t refundable. (I got it in January of 2019) I think this is totally unfair since it’s obviously their fault and not pilot error. What should I do?

Cortes Dronage Posted at 3-24 10:13
Hey guys, two days ago my drone crashed..... I was flying along then out of the blue my battery level dropped from 35 to 0 and I got a message saying critically low battery. I immediately turned around and started to go back to shore but it didn’t make it. I had full deflection forward and up but to no avail; it crashed about a 100 yards out and I wasn’t able to find it. The next morning I called DJI and told them everything but they pulled the stupid move. They said since it wasn’t under warranty anymore it wasn’t refundable. (I got it in January of 2019) I think this is totally unfair since it’s obviously their fault and not pilot error. What should I do?

I'm sorry that you lost your drone, this proves that this "critically Low Voltage Warning" message should be given much sooner. It's absolutely nonsense get this message when it's already an emergency landing situation.... I can't figure out why put this message only in the last moment, unbelievable.

Cell deviation could be shown on the app main screen, for example, once it deviates 20% the first warning is shown, 40% the second and there it goes....then we can fly the drone back safely before it's critical.

Depending where the drone is flying (above water, busy road, properties etc) the operator will have nothing to do to save it.

JonnyHammer Posted at 3-24 11:01
I'm sorry that you lost your drone, this proves that this "critically Low Voltage Warning" message should be given much sooner. It's absolutely nonsense get this message when it's already an emergency landing situation.... I can't figure out why DJI developers decided to put this message only in the last moment, unbelievable.

The correct way to avoid this is to show cell deviation on the app main screen, for example, once it deviates 20% the first warning is shown, 40% the second and there it goes....it's so simple, then we can fly the drone back safely before it's critical.

You think there is anything I could do? Is there anything that could change their mind? At the very least there should be a place where we could write a letter bringing this to attention.

Cortes Dronage Posted at 3-26 11:32
You think there is anything I could do? Is there anything that could change their mind? At the very least there should be a place where we could write a letter bringing this to attention.

You can write to DJI support, maybe they have an option for criticisms or complaints. There are moderators on the chat as well.

JJB* Posted at 2020-1-17 11:50
Hiya,

Looks like a bad #2 cell, see chart.
[Image]

What is the Name of this application?