Iancraig10
First Officer
United Kingdom
Offline
|
m326 Posted at 1-25 07:58
Twice on Black Friday I tried to order a GoPro 11 from their website and twice my order was cancelled telling me to buy it locally so I ordered the OA3 instead and picture wise I don't have any complaints, I just need to get this audio sorted out better having bought a DJI tested and compatible microphone.
In my screenshot of the audio in RX, it shows the level is already low but clipping, if DJI were to give us a greater range of attenuation, when we then raise the volume (gain) would that not increase the noise floor? Writing that I remember hearing on several occasions, even with DJI's own wireless mic system the user has to attenuate both the transmitter signal and the receivers signal by -12db each... and that seems to work for moto vloggers. So even their own mic setup doesn't work too great with the OA3... assuming it works perfectly well in other applications.
Basically, the louder the signal at source the better. Not so loud that the mic is overloaded though. So loud microphone into attenuated preamp is best and gives the lowest noise. The problem here is that even with -12dB, motorbike people will suffer because they probably need to raise their voices above an already loud engine. Plus the fact that the mic is enclosed in a helmet! That is hard for a microphone. It's like shouting over a hammer drill! I'm guessing that speedboats would have a worse problem because they don't even wear a helmet to cover the mic. Probably why so many have no audio and music covers it all up!!
I have to say, I can’t see cheap mics being any better really because most tend to have similar sensitivity, cheap or expensive. Cheap mics sound ok, but they tend to have more self noise and are more 'coloured' sounding on the whole. The more expensive mics just sound better. The Rode mic that the op is using is an excellent lavalier and actually not too expensive. Some lavs are very expensive and I did try a pro one on the Action …… it distorts close up. About 6 inches away and most of my lavs settle down.
Self noise or preamp noise isn’t an issue on a motorbike. Because of this problem, I might try to plant the lav on one ear (like glasses), or down at my throat. Or even to the side of my mouth. That might just be enough to get rid of the distortion until DJI do something. (If anything)
Another workaround is to put another lead in line with a volume control. They are available for headphones but can work with microphones that are too loud. It will raise noise, but won’t be noticeable on a motorbike.
The Action mic indicator when recording does go red when it overmodulate, so it’s dead easy to adjust by watching the indicator. If it goes red, turn the mic down.
Only other option which won’t be liked is a recorder in your pocket to be sync’d later.
To be honest, audio for video can be very tricky at the best of times. Most Action users just accept what they get and never really worry about how bad their audio is! You’d be surprised how good Action footage appears subjectively, if the audio is good. It really raises the perceived quality which is why I have so many microphones and bits of recording gear here. Poor quality video is actually more acceptable than poor quality audio. Audio distortion is just painful!!
The in line volume control would fix this if DJI do nothing. |
|