Mark The Droner
Second Officer
Flight distance : 2917 ft
United States
Offline
|
Well, there are plenty of opinions. There are plenty of people who insist a deep discharge only damages the battery and nothing good can come from it.
Yeah the "intending to store them long term" throws me off too. It sounds like, if we flew yesterday, and don't plan to fly again in three months, we should do the deep discharge today. That doesn't make much sense. I'd love to hear an explanation.
I am not aware of a 10% deep discharge threshold. I don't think the critical low has anything to do with it. MHO
In the P2 days, the manual said "below 8%" which means 7% or less. And it was supposed to be done routinely regardless of storage.
There was a guy who did a bunch of tests on the P2 batteries a long while back - and he determined that a P2 lipo MUST be discharged less than 8% in order to trigger the recalibration of the cells. Going down to 9% would accomplish nothing, he said. There was a software trigger that took place, he said.
Then with the new P3, it was "to 8%" which means to 8% but not 7% and not 9%. I thought maybe the language was a typo.
Then that recommendation disappeared. It just vanished right off the manual pages.
Now it's apparently 5%, although it doesn't say that in any manuals, but that's only if we store for 3 months, or intend to store for three months, I guess.
But the 5% makes sense somewhat when you consider that the FW of these more modern batteries is deliberately designed to mislead us regarding the actual percentage of power - meaning 0% is not really 0% anymore like it used to be. 0% is now a higher voltage/cell then it used to be - which is to say 0% is the new 3%, so to speak. Something like that. I believe DJI does this deliberately to keep us from killing our batteries while in flight and losing our aircrafts.
So if you consider that, then the 5% discharge makes sense - relative to the old 8%...
...
I'm sure there will be plenty of members who will enjoy coming in here and tearing this up.
<shrug>
Anyway, what do I care? I fly year round. I haven't deep discharged a healthy battery in years.
...
MHO
|
|