hallmark007
Captain
Flight distance : 9827923 ft
Ireland
Offline
|
Cookster670 Posted at 1-22 01:34
At the end of the day, RTH speed is not al imitation of the drone, it’s of the software. The mini can fly in wind conditions in excess of it’s RTH speed, How would people feel if DJI decided to halve it’s RTH speed? Do we say “well that’s the limitation of the drone and DJI made it for good reasons, so don’t fly in windy conditions in excess of that”. No, we wouldn’t because we know it’s capable of more.
Im sure DJI chose it’s RTH speed for good reasons at the time, but given the amount of posts we see about lost or almost lost Minis as a result of RTH speed, Then I would hope they would revisit this. In the posts that I’ve read and remember, the Mini was flying around ok in the windy conditions UNTIL RTH kicked in.
Everybody keeps saying that the mini can fly safely in higher winds than 18mph, yet the manual and the disclaimer manual clearly tells you the safe limit for flying the mini is 18mph, almost 50% less than it’s top sport speed.
This is also in keeping with safe speeds on all other dji craft where there is a threshold for Rth speed, are we saying now this has nothing to do with safety at all.
So let’s say we do the same for all dji craft and so it’s now safe to have the inspire flying no longer under the control of an operator at 58mph, I for one would not think this is safe.
I think when dji rate their craft they do so to air on the safe side that’s correct, and this follows patterns of safety for many things in life, safety always airs on the cautious side and for very good reason.
We know that Mavic mini can be flown in Rth at approx 24mph and why what is the difference in the operator being able to increase speed to 24mph in Rth mode, but without operator it can only fly 18mph, it seems the only difference is the operator, in other words someone in charge of controlling the craft, once you hit Rth or craft looses signal and goes to Rth your craft is no longer flying under the control of the operator.
I don’t believe dji is holding back anything here and I think safety is primarily the issue, it’s all very well to say we should have an emergency button on our craft and only use in emergencies, human nature will tell you this is a complete non runner.
Lastly if we had this option of craft being increased to 29mph, what do you think would happen if someone flew in 30mph and lost his craft.
Well I’ll tell you, he would come on here and say there was almost no wind on the ground it couldn’t have been more than 20mph at 30m altitude he checked UAV, and is now demanding his warranty, remember dji craft don’t record wind speed, so where’s the proof you can get weather forecast but which one they all will vary, and your back in the same situation and you have the same people blaming everything but themselves.
We buy this craft there are limits with it, but what we see from a few is they bought something that doesn’t fly and do all the things the next craft up does, so they start to demand changes.
On the other hand we have those who buy something know what they bought learn how to work with what they bought produce some very fine photography and get on with life . |
|