yorlik
lvl.3
United States
Offline
|
Panama, I think we are arguing over semantics and saying the same thing.
It appears you are arguing that a smart charger/discharge_monitor, such as in our dji batts, is safer than not having such smarts. OK. I don't think anyone will argue that.
But your writing makes it appear you are saying the lipo chemistry used in dji is different than all other lipos, and that is flat wrong as I am sure you can agree.
THAT is what we have been arguing with you - the dji batt lipo is same as the rest in the world, NO DIFFERENCE.
NOw, that said, let's go on to the other points you mention last....
You say 3.7v is nominal, not 20% charge left point. Sounds reasonable, but neither you or anyone else has put up the exact charge and discharge voltage curve for the dji batteries. As again I am sure you know, lipo designs ARE slightly different from mfgr to mfgr, and if you google lipo charge or lipo discharge curve, you can find many examples - SOME of which show 20% remaining charge @ about 3.7v. It is a function of the EXACT chemistry used.
But beyond that, the other post stated clearly that this 80% USED, AKA 20% left point, IS SHOWN IN ASSISTANT AND ON OUR DJI BATT LITES AS 1 LITE AND 20% REMAINING. I don't think Jato made that up; he is relating what dji THEMSELVES call 20% remaining for THEIR battery as identified by the 1 lite left and assistant actual data. Not arguable point other than questioning if there is error in Jato's observations. NOw if you personally disagree with dji's assessment of THEIR battery 20% & full charge points, I am not sure how far you will get getting past the marketeers who seem to have way too much input into engineering in this company, but if you DO get hold of a real charge and real discharge set of curves for our 5200mah batteries, I for one will love to see it! |
|