What do you think? which one are you choosing?

Pocket 2 many times (except when I need waterproof / shockproof)

I love what you did with the title...  very clever.

PS,  Im waiting for the P3.

I have P2 and I love it, but I doesn't use it as much as I should.

I've been waiting for someone to do this comparison. Excellent job.

It's the Pocket 2 for me. Action 2 doesn't seem bad for it's purposes, but my video material is more like everyday documentary, rather than extreme conditions. The functions of the Pocket 2 serve me better, but I am certain the Action 2 is the right choice for some people.

I have Pocket 1 and love it. Pocket 2 has few improvements but still it can't encode 4K footage to h265 that i expected to be honest so video stream is limited to 100kbps h264 that is the same as Pocket 1 bitrate is way too low (never mind bigger sensor)
That's why I decided to try Action 2. Well, it has its own but limited application not up to my style but I do like h265 encoding (wondering why Pocket 2 still does not have it), I am not sure if it is really worth upgrading Pocket 1 to Pocket 2. I would wait for "3". However if I hear that DJI enabled h265 in pocket 2 and solves the issue with junk files then I will be happy to buy Pocket 2