[POLL] who is thinking about go for Air 3 instead of A2s?
12Next >
3965 68 2023-7-25
Uploading and Loding Picture ...(0/1)
o(^-^)o
fateofangel
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1397238 ft
Poland
Offline

who is thinking about go for Air 3 instead of A2s?


Single SelectVote, Total 95 people participate in voting
Your user group with no voting privileges
2023-7-25
Use props
The Saint
First Officer
Flight distance : 5902228 ft
  • >>>
United States
Offline

im sure it's tempting for current air2s flyers but i think it's a hair under to hold off....not forever but prob just until the end of the year.
2023-7-25
Use props
fateofangel
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1397238 ft
Poland
Offline

Battery and O4 are gamechangers and the pricepoint is very atractive in my opinion
2023-7-25
Use props
RobZilla
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1057844 ft
  • >>>
United States
Offline

Dual lens looks promising as well as the battery charger hub. The new charging hub can take the low batteries and transfer the charge to a battery with more juice.

But like most, will wait for further reviews and like past DJI products, a few more firmware iterations ie fixes.
2023-7-25
Use props
Mastoras
lvl.4
Flight distance : 558517 ft
  • >>>
United States
Offline

Air 3 beats it in every single category, its an easy pick. Also the camera is better, and it especially blows it away in low light and night shots. Its actually even slightly better then Mini 3 camera even if its same sensor size. If i didnt have a drone and was looking between the two, yes, definitely Air 3.
2023-7-25
Use props
Dan Jurak
lvl.2

Canada
Offline

Until I see a RAW image from the Air 3 and am convinced that the image quality is superior to that of the Air 2S I am on the fence.
2023-7-25
Use props
fateofangel
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1397238 ft
Poland
Offline

i like this guy reviews
2023-7-25
Use props
The Saint
First Officer
Flight distance : 5902228 ft
  • >>>
United States
Offline

Also I heard the Air 3 has waypoints so the Air crowd won't have to be as worried as the SDK right away.
2023-7-25
Use props
Darkozi
lvl.3
Flight distance : 3678986 ft
Serbia
Offline

I would sit and wait for the Air 3s or Pro whatever it will be called. Just for the sensor to be better. This sounds to me as a step back, if double lens is excluded.
2023-7-25
Use props
Freetime
Second Officer
Flight distance : 3395469 ft
United States
Offline

Darkozi Posted at 7-25 08:48
I would sit and wait for the Air 3s or Pro whatever it will be called. Just for the sensor to be better. This sounds to me as a step back, if double lens is excluded.

It is not a a step backwards.
2023-7-25
Use props
djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW
lvl.2
United States
Offline

Mastoras Posted at 7-25 07:44
Air 3 beats it in every single category, its an easy pick. Also the camera is better, and it especially blows it away in low light and night shots. Its actually even slightly better then Mini 3 camera even if its same sensor size. If i didnt have a drone and was looking between the two, yes, definitely Air 3.

It doesn't?

Cost: 2x the cost of a used perfect condition air 2s, air 2s with flymore is $600-700 USD

air 2s batteries are $30-40 new on ebay (air 3 is like 3x this)

air 2s can use the old smart controller OR the new smart controller, the air 3 can't

air 3 has a smaller sensor and arguably worse footage, although its close

air 3 has a lower resolution, 4k vs 5.4k

THE ONLY things that the air 3 is better with is battery length, zoom capabilities, and obstacle avoidance.

Its too close to the mavic 3 series in price (classic is about the same price or less used, and is better)
2023-7-26
Use props
djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW
lvl.2
United States
Offline

Freetime Posted at 7-25 10:06
It is not a a step backwards.

heres a few points it is

4k vs 5.4k

1/1.3" vs 1"

New controller and batteries which are likely not compatible with the old setup, which the air 2s can do

Pricier accessories ($159 battery vs $34 on ebay for air 2s, new)

only advantages:
Obstacle avoidance (shouldnt be relied on anyway for filming)
Zoom camera
Flight time (but at 5x the battery cost, 50% more flight time seems not very important)
2023-7-26
Use props
Freetime
Second Officer
Flight distance : 3395469 ft
United States
Offline

djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW Posted at 7-26 13:27
heres a few points it is

4k vs 5.4k

A new dual camera setup,new updated controller with better signal,46 minute battery life.
Wow real downgrades.I have an Air 2 and to put it bluntly the battery life plain sucks.The
new stacked CMOS sensors in the Air 3 will probably equal or most likely surpass the image
quality of the Air2s.So if you are happy with the basically garbage flight times on the air 2 s
more power to you I guess.When camera still photo comparisons start coming in between the Air 3
and Air 2s.Guess which will win ,it has too, new technology versus a two year old sensor.1" or not
Out with the old and in with modern technology.
2023-7-26
Use props
djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW
lvl.2
United States
Offline

Freetime Posted at 7-26 17:49
A new dual camera setup,new updated controller with better signal,46 minute battery life.
Wow real downgrades.I have an Air 2 and to put it bluntly the battery life plain sucks.The
new stacked CMOS sensors in the Air 3 will probably equal or most likely surpass the image
Never said it didn’t have ANY upgrades

You claimed it was an upgrade in every way

It is not, it has a lot of compromises
“Upgraded controller” that isn’t compatible with ANY other drones, what a lame controller

, where the Dji air 2s can use the old smart controller and the newer one,

It’s a shame this new drone is just full of compromises, and sure it had a worse battery life, but the batteries are $35 per, versus $159, I can get 5 batteries for the same price as one…..
2023-7-26
Use props
Freetime
Second Officer
Flight distance : 3395469 ft
United States
Offline

djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW Posted at 7-26 17:53
Never said it didn’t have ANY upgrades

You claimed it was an upgrade in every way

It is not sinking in yet is it.lol.But it will.
We differ here and a lot will agree with me here,so let go of the old technology.
All done.
2023-7-26
Use props
djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW
lvl.2
United States
Offline

Freetime Posted at 7-26 18:00
It is not sinking in yet is it.lol.But it will.
We differ here and a lot will agree with me here,so let go of the old technology.
All done.

Don't get me wrong, the air 3 is cool

but at that price point, a use mavic 3 classic, or a mavic 3 pro is better,  its not a "budget option" anymore

an air 2s is literally half the cost, and cross compatible,

the air 3 is a one off drone with technology that only supports itself, and isnt even as good as similarly priced drones, like the mavic 3 classic, and is WORSE in someways than way cheaper drones.

Let go of a bad decision, get the mavic 3 pro if you wanted an upgrade, or wait for the air 3s
2023-7-26
Use props
angeloffate
lvl.4
Poland
Offline

Air 3
2023-7-26
Use props
Hallmark007
Captain
Flight distance : 9827923 ft
  • >>>
Ireland
Offline

djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW Posted at 7-26 17:53
Never said it didn’t have ANY upgrades

You claimed it was an upgrade in every way

Every new dji controller was only compatible with one dji drone on release except crystalsky , yet in a matter of a short time firmware was released to make them compatible with other drones. If you expected anything different you’re completely naive.
There are many many good improvements, but there is not a single dji drone on the market that has everything on a whishlist .
2023-7-27
Use props
Hallmark007
Captain
Flight distance : 9827923 ft
  • >>>
Ireland
Offline

djiuser_R2E4mZMfdqKW Posted at 7-26 13:27
heres a few points it is

4k vs 5.4k

It’s not about 50% more flying time, how many shots missed bringing craft to land to change batteries only to realise you may never get that light again. And for someone who is comparing 5.4 k to 4k you should understand this , you also can’t compare the price of air2s now to the release price of air3 , thats just nonsense.
2023-7-27
Use props
sduck
Second Officer
Flight distance : 4315098 ft
United States
Offline

Question: does the 3 have waypoints? Besides in hyperlapse? Has anyone actually seen this in all the demo videos? (I have yet to wade through all the hype, sorry)Edit: Yes, according to the manual, it does have waypoint flight. Which has been promised for the 2S for years - come on DJI, you can still add it!

Also: will it work with the RC Pro upon arrival? Or is it a wait until they send out a firmware upgrade?
2023-7-27
Use props
Mini-G
Second Officer
Flight distance : 663304 ft
  • >>>
Australia
Offline

I have the air 2s and feeling I should stretch the funds and get the Mavic 3 Pro?
I’m after image quality and was hoping the air 3 would inherit the original Mavic 3 lens/sensor set up without the Hasselblad colour configuration
2023-7-27
Use props
Hallmark007
Captain
Flight distance : 9827923 ft
  • >>>
Ireland
Offline

sduck Posted at 7-27 06:39
Question: does the 3 have waypoints? Besides in hyperlapse? Has anyone actually seen this in all the demo videos? (I have yet to wade through all the hype, sorry)Edit: Yes, according to the manual, it does have waypoint flight. Which has been promised for the 2S for years - come on DJI, you can still add it!

Also: will it work with the RC Pro upon arrival? Or is it a wait until they send out a firmware upgrade?

Yes it has full waypoints and no out of the box it will only work with the two remotes it's sold with. I would imaging compatibility will come shortly and this is always the way dii release its new products.
2023-7-27
Use props
Shawgod
Second Officer
Flight distance : 5173104 ft
United States
Offline

I would love to upgrade in a heartbeat.  I just purchased my Air2S in January.  I love the drone, don't love some things.  But I can't afford to Spend all the money I did to go for an upgrade so close right now.  I have 8 batteries, a nanuk case and I paid for the warranty from DJI.  I have to at least fly it for a couple years before upgrading to a new drone.  That is pretty much what I did with my Phantom 4 Pro.  With the onset of the Remote ID coming up.  I didn't want to mess around with getting a module for it so I decided to purchase a new drone that had it built in.  Maybe someday down the line I will buy a module for it when they are cheaper.  But I can't justify spending $300 for a module right now.  I would rather spend it on a new drone.  The Air 2S is still a great drone hands down.  Granted it doesn't have all the cool features the Air 3 has, but that goes for all new products that come out.  I will be all in when they have the Air 3S or Air 4.  But for now I have my Air2S.
2023-7-27
Use props
fansc10478d9
New

United Kingdom
Offline

I have the Air 2S and use it for still photography. I was very keen on buying the 3 based on the jump from 20 to 48MP.
But having just watched a few reviews I am hearing the the 48mp is a bit of a myth. Is there a way to see example RAW files?

Also, which DJI do people recommend for still photography (that is £1500 or below).
2023-7-28
Use props
Mark_F
lvl.3
Flight distance : 376594 ft
  • >>>
United States
Offline

fansc10478d9 Posted at 7-28 09:15
I have the Air 2S and use it for still photography. I was very keen on buying the 3 based on the jump from 20 to 48MP.
But having just watched a few reviews I am hearing the the 48mp is a bit of a myth. Is there a way to see example RAW files?

I have heard that people will still recommend the air 2s for still photography.  For video, it will be the Air 3.
If I am in the market to upgrade by then, I will hold off for specs on air 3s or air 3 pro.  

2023-7-28
Use props
Manuel Perez
lvl.4
Flight distance : 2195282 ft
Uruguay
Offline

In my case isn't necessary change and in my country dji seller is a lie...
2023-7-29
Use props
Vapormatt
lvl.4
United Kingdom
Offline

i will be sticking to my Air 2s. Maybe i might look again at air 3s if good improvements but no Air 3 for me.
2023-8-1
Use props
bjr981s
Second Officer
Flight distance : 139698 ft
  • >>>
Australia
Offline

Air 3 as I already have an Air 2S.
2023-8-1
Use props
Max_Plastix
lvl.2
United States
Offline

One big gap in the Air 3 is 3rd-Party apps, SDK, and (mapping) automation.  The Air 2S is well-supported by the app ecosystem, while the Air 3 is not likely to be for some time, if ever.  (Mini 3 Pro, same)
The controller does not support third-party apps at all.

It does have Waypoints, but they are very buggy.  The Fly app will crash and exit, or the whole UI freezes up if you have too many waypoints or try to move too quickly on the map.

Further, the waypoints have a mandatory "curve fit" that makes them useless for drawing grids, rectangles.. anything with straight lines.. all waypoint paths are curved.

All in all, as an Air3 owner, I'm now thinking I might add an Air 2S just for ortho maps and such.  Air3 is not fully baked yet.
2023-8-3
Use props
drone036
lvl.2

United States
Offline

I have to say, DJI's updates are great, I can't always decide when to buy the right drone.
2023-8-3
Use props
fateofangel
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1397238 ft
Poland
Offline

Air 3 convience me, i desire it i must admit. This EU c1 certification aswell is an true advantage for me
2023-8-6
Use props
Jake.A
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1205715 ft
United States
Offline

Although the sensor is smaller, the inmage quality is still better. So air 3 for me.
2023-8-9
Use props
fateofangel
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1397238 ft
Poland
Offline

Jake.A Posted at 8-9 04:32
Although the sensor is smaller, the inmage quality is still better. So air 3 for me.

im curious if it is rocessor and software thing or what
2023-8-20
Use props
Montfrooij
Captain
Flight distance : 2560453 ft
  • >>>
Netherlands
Offline

A3 is in many ways a big upgrade for sure.
2023-8-25
Use props
angeloffate
lvl.4
Poland
Offline

ill borrow Air 3, i  will see if it will be enough for me or ill fall ill to buy it
2023-8-31
Use props
djiuser_zKR5HFX3a2EC
lvl.4
Flight distance : 474537 ft
United States
Offline

If you don't have an air 2s. Go for the air 3 is a no brainer. If you already have an air 2s. Why the hell do you need to upgrade?
2023-8-31
Use props
AlexanderK
lvl.4
Flight distance : 2023829 ft
  • >>>
Netherlands
Offline

For Film: Air 3. For photography: Air 2S
2023-9-3
Use props
AlexanderK
lvl.4
Flight distance : 2023829 ft
  • >>>
Netherlands
Offline

djiuser_zKR5HFX3a2EC Posted at 8-31 17:42
If you don't have an air 2s. Go for the air 3 is a no brainer. If you already have an air 2s. Why the hell do you need to upgrade?

For film the telelens adds a whole new perspective. That would be a great reason. Another is way better batteries. Flight times are beter. And flying a set path and repeat it is for me a very nice feature. We shoot long construction projects etc. For photography I'll stick to my Air2s since the tiny sensor and the '48mp' from the Air 3 are insanely bad
2023-9-3
Use props
Ken98045
lvl.1
Flight distance : 115039 ft
United States
Offline

I'm new to drones, but...   I strongly considered a heavily discounted (or used) 2S.  However, I did eventually decide to go with the 3 due to the dual cameras/sensors.  

However, I'm deeply disappointed that you can't switch cameras mid video.  I see no reasonable reason why the hardware would prevent this (or couldn't easily been designed to support it).  If it isn't hardware, it's software.  I'm a software guy (30+ years) who has worked with fixed security cameras for a long time so I have some reasonably informed opinions on this.  If this is a software issue then:

1.   It was a really lazy/under enormous pressure Project Manager who made the decision not to support camera switches, or
2.  Some incompetent Software Engineers.  or
3.  Some senior managers that just couldn't see the importance of this feature.

Note that for many, many phone cameras the camera switch is so seamless that you will often not know which camera is actually being used for which portions of a video at the momenet.  If they can do it, DJI can do it!  At a minimum just let me switch cameras.  If the video jumps that is on me.  Yes, ideally one continous zoom would be nice, but I'm not asking for that (now).


I sincerely hope it is just a software issue that will be fixed in a firmware update.
2023-9-6
Use props
DJI Tony
Administrator

Offline

Ken98045 Posted at 9-6 16:57
I'm new to drones, but...   I strongly considered a heavily discounted (or used) 2S.  However, I did eventually decide to go with the 3 due to the dual cameras/sensors.  

However, I'm deeply disappointed that you can't switch cameras mid video.  I see no reasonable reason why the hardware would prevent this (or couldn't easily been designed to support it).  If it isn't hardware, it's software.  I'm a software guy (30+ years) who has worked with fixed security cameras for a long time so I have some reasonably informed opinions on this.  If this is a software issue then:

Thank you for your recommendations. Please rest assured that we will register the information and provide feedback to the related departments for evaluation. In the future, we will optimize and improve the product or service based on user comments. Thank you for your support and understanding.
2023-9-8
Use props
12Next >
Advanced
You need to log in before you can reply Login | Register now

Credit Rules