SimplePanda
Second Officer
Flight distance : 1719062 ft
Canada
Offline
|
So, having watched this on a 4K panel (understanding that YouTube isn't the best delivery mechanism), my thoughts are:
- I don't agree the X3 footage looks better. It's sometimes not "worse", but I don't think it's ever "better".
- On the contrary, the X5 looks better in some shots, for sure.
- I think the grading and processing has a lot to do with how similar looking the two images can be at times.
- X5 DOES have noticeably better dynamic range, as DJI said it would. Shadows in the darker shots, especially, show this off.
- The X3 footage is definitely the X3 we know and "love" - aggressive sharpening with ugly aliasing.
- The X5 is definitely "softer" but I'm wondering if this was because of the capture settings. Is the sharpness on the X5 implemented differently than the X3 or were the settings just turned way down for this footage?
I'd love to know what the settings were for sharpening, log/colour profile, etc. Would help to determine if this was a true side by side comparison or if the X5 was just being shot and processed poorly. Overall, there are some improvements in the X5 footage for sure but again, without seeing the original MP4/MOV files and knowing what settings were being used it's hard to compare them properly.
That said...
As it stands I'm strongly leaning to the idea that the X5 is a bit of a misstep by DJI.
Based on what I've seen so far in terms of raw footage, DJI released footage, and the initial customer footage coming out there are just many shortcomings to justify $2500 CAD for this unit. Even if you assume the gimbal accounts for $500 of the price, the footage we've seen so far in no way suggests that $2000 worth of camera is at work here.
To be clear - the dollar amount doesn't bother me. I'm willing to pay a lot more than $2500 for a camera that delivers an image that is worth what's being asked for it. This isn't an issue of cost, it's one of value. The X5 seems like a very incremental upgrade over the X3, except costing 5x the money (in CAD).
If DJI priced the X5 in the $1000 (CAD) range (without a lens, of course) I'd probably have ordered one sight unseen based on the spec sheet alone. But $2500 (no lens)? The X5 just isn't in that league based on everything we've been shown so far.
Waiting to see what the X5R can do.
|
|