Many times I have seen posts whereby a pilot has started with a partially used stored battery, subsequently had problems with their Phantom very quickly going Critical low battery and either forcing a landing/RTH or a crash.
For a few weeks I have been trying to understand why a seemingly Healthy Battery Pack with around 70% or 80% capacity would within minutes go Critically Low.
To experiment I purposely discharged my fully charged batteries to around 70%, left them for around 3-5 days, and then put them in my P3 and hovered around 1.5m off the ground and kept an eye on battery status. (note: self-discharge is set to 10 days and I have not stored more then 3-5 days - so it’s out of the equation) also I have tried to be consistent with temperature, and always done the test when external/air temp is around 20C.
Today I believe I recreated the issue!!
The temperature was around 22C when I did the test and weather was sunny, no wind. I took a partially charged battery that had been stored for 5 days and put it in the P3, after switching on (unarmed) it showed 66% charged battery, voltage per cell was 3.98V on all cells except for cell#1 that was 3.99 (negligible difference) I brought up the Battery monitoring screen (to keep an eye on the battery) and to my surprise less than a minute gentle hovering (no drastic moves) into the flight the Voltage very quickly Dropped lower than it should be to around 3.58V and Yellow lined! - Note Battery is at 61% Capacity and only 1:13 minutes into the flight drops significantly Voltage Low in a very short time and stayed yellow. - See Screen Capture/Pic.
It also shows that I have around 12 minutes of flight time left - But with Voltage this Low I not sure that i could make anything close to this.
It’s my understanding the battery Percentage capacity is calculated, by the smart circuitry in the Pack, from how much mAH has gone into the battery at charge, and how much has been used when its being discharged. - IT HAS NO RELATION TO THE VOLTAGE OF THE PACK
Therefor a discrepancy may exist, whereby the voltage of a pack may drop dangerously low, whilst the Percentage indicator still shows sufficient capacity. I believe this has been the issue that many Pilots who have crashed on partially charged packs have suffered from.
So the lesson learnt is:
- Charge packs fully before flying.. - Try not to use partially charged packs, especially if they have been left for a few days.
- If you do use a partially charged pack, then hover for around a minute, and keep a Hawks Eye on each battery Voltage. - if any battery quickly drops to under 3.60v in around 1.5 minutes or less then stop flying and change the battery.
- Do not use the Percentage as the only indicator to determine the state of the battery. - Turn On "Show the voltage on the main screen" and keep an eye on it. - if it goes yellow and stays yellow, then start to prepare to come back home or land somewhere safe.
If somebody can comment or has an explanation please let us know as i'm always keen to learn.
(and before anybody looks at the pic and starts to Holler that im hovering in a built up area - I have explicit permission from All my neighbours to fly in MY yard and I never fly/hover higher then 5 meters when im there. besides two of my neighbours fly drones as well. )
|