Ray-CubeAce
lvl.4
United Kingdom
Offline
|
chrisnatterer Posted at 8-13 13:11
Could it be a faulty unit? Someone posted a video in another thread of someone testing two different units of the microphone adapter. One seems to work far better than the other.
Early on a few of us on the forum published the results of our audio adaptors. Some of us using the same or similar mics had the same results as each other so I don't think so. Certainly, there were problems with some units but my results were the same as others who had the least problems. I do wonder about the fact there have been no new Osmo Pocket audio adapters for sale on the DJI site for some time now and no audio adapter made available yet for the Osmo Action.
I've looked at teardown videos on the net and found which analog to digital audio converters were used and found the spec sheets for those converters and read them. There are warnings about how to use them in production in those specs and how they should be put to use and additional components needed to resolve those issues that need implementation as well as how to program them if they have used the programmable version of the chip.
However, so far DJI has not responded to one request about specs or answered any specific questions put forward by users as far as I'm aware. Maybe it can be fixed by a firmware update when plugged into the Pocket or maybe the problems will persist, or maybe DJI feels the audio adapters are working to spec and some of us users are being too fussy about the results we are getting.
For instance, DJI continually insists the audio unit is dual-channel but stop short of ever saying it is stereo which users have clearly demonstrated it is not and asked why not.
DJI initially made the use of the two internal mics to noise cancel outside wind noise (hence the odd positioning of the mics on the Osmo Pockets body) but there were a lot of complaints about the quality of the audio from the inbuilt mics. There was a subsequent firmware update that improved that but no explanation of how it was achieved. Not that any was needed as most people were pleased with the upgraded quality of the audio output from the internal mics even though wind noise cancelation decreased as a result. That was preferable to the previous audio quality of the output.
This was all done before the release of the audio adapter. If that update has somehow affected how the audio adapter now works with the Pocket, no-one knows or can guess at.
The audio adapter seems to be as it is with some mics like yours that in theory should work but don't.
No-ne really as a good explanation as to why.
I'm detecting a DC offset I hadn't noticed before on my recordings but on backward review of earlier recordings I made seems to have always been there but I hadn't noticed. So far no-one here has replied to my post to say they have a similar result or not. Maybe they haven't seen my post or no longer care that much anymore and are resigned to the results as they are 'good enough' to work with.
I would have liked some replies to see if it was just my unit or not but without feedback from other users, I can't honestly say. It could be a fault with my unit that doesn't exist in other units but I don't think so.
I can work with my unit. The quality is sufficient to work with additional external editing but removing DC offset from every clip will be an extra bit of editing I would prefer not to have to do.
Some users have resorted to using a separate recording device so as to get a stereo soundtrack and have affectively abandoned using the Pockets audio beyond may be using it to sync to their external recorders, so maybe no longer care.
I just feel your mic should have worked along with a lot of other mics that don't work and I'm a bit miffed there are no real explanations.
|
|