I've sent my P4P back
1122 6 2017-5-13
Uploading and Loding Picture ...(0/1)
o(^-^)o
Crio
Second Officer
Flight distance : 67713 ft
  • >>>
United Kingdom
Offline

By any means this is not a rant or moun of any sort.
I just want to share my experience with P4P that I've bought as a P4 replacement.

I placed the order on Thursday last week in one of the shops in UK, received the bird on Monday.
As standard... charged the bat. , done the FW update, calibrated all and noticed strange noises from the gimbal itself.
My previous P4 has some gimbal noises that was corrected by firmware update so my P4P has them as gimbal was initialising. I thought ''No biggy, still works''

The weather was great that day so I went to perform maiden flight. this was the first time I've noticed ''High interfierence warning'' flashing every few seconds.
It was weird as I was using the same spot with my P4 for over a year but ok...its just a message I said to myself. This is not affecting the way it fly ( I was hoping ).

I read the forum before I pulled the trigger and I knew there will be High Wind Velocity warnings, and they were.

I've also noticed that when I arm my motors, and Phantom increase the throttle twice before take off ( zoom, zoom effect ;) ) it performs diferently than my P4 and other P4Ps that I've saw. After those standard 2 throttle bumps the amount of constant throttle given by the bird was really low, and I mean really... To the point the only thing you could hear was the fan inside the aircraft not the actual motors or proppelers.

In the air it performed differently as well. Even that he didnt have to fight the wind, the sounds it made was not contstand but quick pulsing one. It wasnt so stable as P4 that I had as well. You could tell its feeling unsettled while airborne

On the next day Ive done a different flight in a different location and I've noticed it doesn't fly straight. Instead of flying to the subject, it drifts so you have to make a curve flight path as you correct the bird in flight.

Then on the second flight there was another thing, preaty obvious horizon tilt and horizon drift. ( there is so much about it that its pointless to explain what everyone know already about this hidden feature ;) ) Long story short I've spent 2 days trying to correct it by Cold IMUs calibration, gimbal calibration and compas calibration in differnt locations. nothing was helping.

Reading the forum in the same time I found the post about that Noisy gimbal ( this is the original post - CLICK ). This is exactly what I had whith mine and as I know this cannot be resolved by firmware update + everything that I've experience already I decided to return it to the store yesterday. After 3 days of owning my P4P.

The store tried to force me to contact DJI as I did and they wanted me to send it back for repair. But I thought to myself WHY?
This is brand new item from the store not from DJI website and it didnt performing as it should straight from the box. I've contacted the store again and explained my situation and this time I received an RMA number.

So my bird is on its way back to the store for them to check it.
Im dissapointed, angry and sad. I really loved my P4 and now Im regreting I sold it so quickly.
I dont blame anyone ( nor DJI or the store ).
My anger is undirected ;)
I love to fly and take pleasure from it... unfortunatelly P4P didnt gave me any of that

Sorry for the long post, no potato this time



2017-5-13
Use props
jsantacroce
lvl.3
Flight distance : 10036 ft
United States
Offline

Forgive the very very dumb question that I will ask anyway as I got another new P4P yesterday with none of the issues above (except the zoom-zoom which I was used to). Did you remove the gray foam block from around the base of the Gimbal? That's all I got and I assume so but just wanted to check. That of course would may interfere with the flying straight comment but it certainly would affect Gimbal although it may affect IMU\Compass calibrations but not sure.

Good luck.  
2017-5-13
Use props
Crio
Second Officer
Flight distance : 67713 ft
  • >>>
United Kingdom
Offline

Yeah... it was removed I had P4 before and I though it will be seamless transition from P4 to P4P
2017-5-13
Use props
dronist
First Officer
  • >>>
United States
Offline

Crio Posted at 2017-5-13 07:05
Yeah... it was removed  I had P4 before and I though it will be seamless transition from P4 to P4P

Crio,

Sorry man, I have both p4p and p4p+ since the beginning and no issues whatsoever. I guess with every manufacturing process no matter how great they are you are going to get lemon and it happened to you.

Don't give up and get a NEW ONE and wish you luck! Cheers!
2017-5-14
Use props
Crio
Second Officer
Flight distance : 67713 ft
  • >>>
United Kingdom
Offline

dronist Posted at 2017-5-14 16:45
Crio,

Sorry man, I have both p4p and p4p+ since the beginning and no issues whatsoever. I guess with every manufacturing process no matter how great they are you are going to get lemon and it happened to you.

Thank you. Despite so many issues that people have with P4 I didn't have none with mine ( except gimbal failure at 5 mths owning but it was resolved by DJI with exceptional good time and manner ). So Im hoping you're right
2017-5-14
Use props
Frenck
lvl.2
Flight distance : 142723 ft
Italy
Offline

Crio Posted at 2017-5-14 23:46
Thank you. Despite so many issues that people have with P4 I didn't have none with mine ( except gimbal failure at 5 mths owning but it was resolved by DJI with exceptional good time and manner ). So Im hoping you're right

Hi ... Also my P4P + has the same problem as you complain, as in the video you have attached ... I also noticed software problems when using the "Follow me" and "Draw" mode .... after Somehow the application does not communicate more perfectly with the remote control and touch ... sometimes the system reboots while the P4P + is flying ... It is the fifth drive I change and every time I find a different problem .. I even tried this to support DJI replacement for warranty ... It seems to me very difficult for the DJI to provide a fully functional P4P + ... I'm thinking of giving up and waiting for the P5 to be able to exchange ..
2017-5-15
Use props
Crio
Second Officer
Flight distance : 67713 ft
  • >>>
United Kingdom
Offline

Frenck Posted at 2017-5-15 00:08
Hi ... Also my P4P + has the same problem as you complain, as in the video you have attached ... I also noticed software problems when using the "Follow me" and "Draw" mode .... after Somehow the application does not communicate more perfectly with the remote control and touch ... sometimes the system reboots while the P4P + is flying ... It is the fifth drive I change and every time I find a different problem .. I even tried this to support DJI replacement for warranty ... It seems to me very difficult for the DJI to provide a fully functional P4P + ... I'm thinking of giving up and waiting for the P5 to be able to exchange ..

This actually makes me worried
2017-5-15
Use props
Advanced
You need to log in before you can reply Login | Register now

Credit Rules